A Taxpayer v HMRC concerned whether six days spent in the UK in 2015/16 could be ignored under the Statutory Residence Test's exceptional-circumstances rule. The taxpayer won at the First-tier Tribunal, lost at the Upper Tribunal ([2023] UKUT 182 (TCC)) and won at the Court of Appeal ([2025] EWCA Civ 106).
The facts
- The taxpayer moved from the UK to Ireland on 4 April 2015.
- In 2015/16 she received about £8 million in dividends on shares transferred to her by her husband.
- She was in the UK at midnight on 50 days. She had been UK resident in earlier years, and 45 days was the relevant limit on her facts.
- She said six of those days (two in December 2015, four in February 2016) should be ignored because she was caring for her twin sister, who was in crisis, and her sister's children.
- HMRC's assessment, as recorded in the Upper Tribunal decision, was for additional tax of £3,142,550.58.
How the case went
The First-tier Tribunal accepted that the risk of neglect to the children amounted to exceptional circumstances that prevented her leaving. On 28 July 2023 the Upper Tribunal reversed that decision. It held that the circumstances must be objectively exceptional, that "prevent" means more than hinder, and that moral obligation alone is not enough.
On 13 February 2025 the Court of Appeal (Males, Nugee and Falk LJJ) allowed her appeal and restored the First-tier Tribunal's decision. It held that the circumstances should be assessed as a whole, and that a compelling moral obligation can form part of what prevents a person from leaving. We have not found a later decision; check whether there has been one.
What this shows
A few days, not hundreds, sat between two outcomes, and the dispute ran for years across three levels of tribunal and court. The limit was not "45 days for everyone". Different limits apply depending on residence history and UK ties, and how many days count can itself be argued.
The outcome depended on the facts as found, and a similar story may end differently. Whether any particular day can be ignored is for a qualified adviser.